Comments on: Guest Review: The Walking Dead by Robert Kirkman http://www.gamingangels.com/2009/11/guest-review-the-walking-dead-by-robert-kirkman/ Gaming Community for female gamer or girl gamer Thu, 09 Feb 2012 16:21:35 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: AMC orders episodes of The Walking Dead | GamingAngels http://www.gamingangels.com/2009/11/guest-review-the-walking-dead-by-robert-kirkman/comment-page-1/#comment-20998 AMC orders episodes of The Walking Dead | GamingAngels Tue, 30 Mar 2010 15:37:58 +0000 http://www.gamingangels.com/?p=22981#comment-20998 [...] “Dead” tells of the time after a zombie apocalypse and follows a group of survivors, led by police officer Rick Grimes, who travel in search of a secure home. Bernthal plays Grimes’ partner and friend Shane. To learn more about the comic series, you can check out the review previously on GamingAngels.com here. [...] [...] “Dead” tells of the time after a zombie apocalypse and follows a group of survivors, led by police officer Rick Grimes, who travel in search of a secure home. Bernthal plays Grimes’ partner and friend Shane. To learn more about the comic series, you can check out the review previously on GamingAngels.com here. [...]

]]> By: Little Mel http://www.gamingangels.com/2009/11/guest-review-the-walking-dead-by-robert-kirkman/comment-page-1/#comment-12169 Little Mel Wed, 02 Dec 2009 21:32:56 +0000 http://www.gamingangels.com/?p=22981#comment-12169 Well, I'm very sorry that you feel this way. However, I do not feel it is doing you or I any good to resort to saying things such as, "this review sucks". You make several points as to why you do not like my review, but tell me what can I learn and how can I respect the opinion of someone who says, "this sucks". Obviously the people on this site like my reviews. In fact, for a while this was basically my blog. Well, that is to say I was the main person writing it. I am only a guest now because I stopped updating, but that is neither here nor there. Let me address some of your point. I did not say main characters die, I said "don't get too attached to a character no matter how main they may SEEM". This is saying 1. A character could seem like a main character, but isn't or 2. Yes, a character that is main, dies. However, unlike a lot of comic books in Walking Dead almost every character has a main part. I am sorry you jumped to the conclusion that you did. As for the way I write my review, everyone is different. I like to give my readers a bit of a preview and leave them wanting more. True, I did not put as much insight into this one as my others, but I ask you to please not judge it because of this. As far as the black and white comments, I admit I have a bit of a learning disability that does not allow me to put thoughts into words, and so I did the best I could. I am unsure as to the importance of telling about the comics creators. If I was reading a review I would not want to be bogged down with a biography of the creators. Rather, I would simply look them up online if interested. As for typos, I know I am bad at grammar, but I am not as smart as everyone else in this context and comments like yours make me feel stupid. I am sorry if this is offensive to you. I think your comment would have been better if you offered suggestions and advice rather than harsh words. Saying "sucks" is not helpful at all. Again, I believe I am a good writer, I am not stupid and I am sorry you disagree. Well, I’m very sorry that you feel this way. However, I do not feel it is doing you or I any good to resort to saying things such as, “this review sucks”. You make several points as to why you do not like my review, but tell me what can I learn and how can I respect the opinion of someone who says, “this sucks”.

Obviously the people on this site like my reviews. In fact, for a while this was basically my blog. Well, that is to say I was the main person writing it. I am only a guest now because I stopped updating, but that is neither here nor there.

Let me address some of your point. I did not say main characters die, I said “don’t get too attached to a character no matter how main they may SEEM”. This is saying 1. A character could seem like a main character, but isn’t or 2. Yes, a character that is main, dies. However, unlike a lot of comic books in Walking Dead almost every character has a main part. I am sorry you jumped to the conclusion that you did.

As for the way I write my review, everyone is different. I like to give my readers a bit of a preview and leave them wanting more. True, I did not put as much insight into this one as my others, but I ask you to please not judge it because of this. As far as the black and white comments, I admit I have a bit of a learning disability that does not allow me to put thoughts into words, and so I did the best I could.

I am unsure as to the importance of telling about the comics creators. If I was reading a review I would not want to be bogged down with a biography of the creators. Rather, I would simply look them up online if interested. As for typos, I know I am bad at grammar, but I am not as smart as everyone else in this context and comments like yours make me feel stupid. I am sorry if this is offensive to you.

I think your comment would have been better if you offered suggestions and advice rather than harsh words. Saying “sucks” is not helpful at all.

Again, I believe I am a good writer, I am not stupid and I am sorry you disagree.

]]> By: Sara http://www.gamingangels.com/2009/11/guest-review-the-walking-dead-by-robert-kirkman/comment-page-1/#comment-12105 Sara Tue, 01 Dec 2009 20:12:23 +0000 http://www.gamingangels.com/?p=22981#comment-12105 I'm sorry, but this review sucks. First, it's too short. Second, it's basically just a plot summary with very little analysis or insight. Third, it contains spoilers. ("Hello, main characters dying!") Fourth, the reviewer says she thinks black-&-white "fits" with the comic's atmosphere, but she doesn't explain why. Fifth, she says the two artists are jarringly different, but the only difference she can articulate is an elementary comment about differentiating characters. Sixth, she tells us basically nothing about the comic's creators. Seventh, it contains multiple typos. I'm sorry, but this is not a good review. I know it's just a guest review, but what's the point in having guest reviewers if they're not at least able to write well? I’m sorry, but this review sucks. First, it’s too short. Second, it’s basically just a plot summary with very little analysis or insight. Third, it contains spoilers. (“Hello, main characters dying!”) Fourth, the reviewer says she thinks black-&-white “fits” with the comic’s atmosphere, but she doesn’t explain why. Fifth, she says the two artists are jarringly different, but the only difference she can articulate is an elementary comment about differentiating characters. Sixth, she tells us basically nothing about the comic’s creators. Seventh, it contains multiple typos.

I’m sorry, but this is not a good review. I know it’s just a guest review, but what’s the point in having guest reviewers if they’re not at least able to write well?

]]>